Jesus is Not a Rabbit's Foot

In Young Sheldon, Sheldon attempts to tutor Billy Sparks in math. When Billy questions the existence of "zero"--How can something be nothing?--scientist Sheldon undergoes a crisis of confidence. Billy suggests that Sheldon take the existence of "zero" on faith. In a lovely allusion to the older Sheldon's show--The Big Bang Theory--Sheldon states that the Big Bang was "born out of zero." He and Billy determine to pray to "zero." 

Billy then asks Sheldon to ask Zero to help him pass his math test.  

"Zero's not magic," Sheldon replies. "You still have to study."

"Oh, then I'm going back to Jesus," sweet-natured Billy responds. 

Billy--who does pass his test--is relying on an idea that crops up in Christian discourse: Jesus as lucky charm. 

To put the idea in blunter parlance: Jesus as a pagan god.  

The idea contradicts the gospels as well as the letters of Paul. However, it is quite indicative of the human mindset!   

First, both the four gospels and the letters of Paul make clear that a God who cares about individuals deeply has not sent his Son to give them stuff. Jesus's response to the rich young man--which response is arguably in the same humorous vein as Jesus's statement about the rich getting into heaven--is not to shower the rich young man with bolsters for self-esteem and emotional comfort. His response is to encourage the rich young man to give up everything and follow Jesus. 

Jesus's exhortations inevitably turn the expected on its head. One should love one's neighbor as one's self, not for the sake of networking but because it is how one grows closer to God. One should emulate the Good Samaritan, not to boast but because it is ethically and morally right. Jesus eats with prostitutes and tax collectors. He challenges strictures about what is "acceptable" and praises less-noticed behaviors. He restores the dead to life. The Good News is the Resurrection and all that the Resurrection implies.

Interesting perspective/life journey!
And yet something within the human spirit desperately wants guarantees and pay-offs. I do not blame religion. Rather, I suggest that this desire is based on mistaking ends and means, events and consequences. Rather than accepting that some things are hard, the goal becomes to escape suffering.  

But reality doesn't work that way. My brother and parents die. I don't have to feel hopeless. I don't have to be miserable. But a rejection of despair and misery doesn't mean I'm not going to miss them, feel a pang now and again when I'm reminded of that loss.  

Events have consequences. Life does change. And yet people "snatch," as Dorothy Sayers would say, at something, anything that might possibly remove those consequences, undo those changes. 

In the original BBC All Creatures Great and Small, James becomes frustrated because he does not, at that time, have a cure for the disease that is destroying his friend's herd. He is also frustrated because the friend's neighbor insists on carrying out a superstitious ritual to try to fix the problem. At one point, as he leaves the barn, James makes eye contact with the neighbor. They are both upset. They both want to help. The ritual will make no difference, and James wants that reality acknowledged. But he does not yet (pre-World War II) have the antibiotics that will make such an enormous difference to the veterinary profession.

The desire for I've-got-it-licked fixes (I'm safe; I'm "in"; I no longer have to worry; it's all good; I've grasped the marker of success) shows up in business, science, education, relationships, and religion.

Within Christianity, this desire focuses on Jesus as a lucky charm or rabbit's foot, a mindset in which Jesus the statue or term is hoarded; in which Jesus the statue or term is worshiped for the sake of worshiping something important for the sake of its importance (which importance will be conferred on the worshiper); in which Jesus the statue or term is expected to remove mess--whether created by human choice or by the conditions of mortality. 

Such Christianity is a revival-like version of "prosperity theology." Instead of financial gain, the gain--through fervent proclamations (I know, I know, I know)--is emotional stability and security.  

A recent sermon presents this version of Christianity by taking scriptures out of context. Although the sermon is real, I have not listed the speaker's name. This example highlights a problem that exists within the entire Christian faith. 

  • "The waters of life" are defined as Jesus Christ's love. But when Jesus addresses the woman at the well, he is referring to what he can give her, namely "eternal life." He states, "Yet a time is coming and has now come when the true worshipers will worship the Father in the Spirit and in truth, for they are the kind of worshipers the Father seeks" (John 4:23, my emphasis) 
  • The speaker references Jesus as a "God of miracles" who can take problems off our hands. But miracles within the gospels are always used to point to Jesus's purpose. He does not perform miracles to impress (and often commands the recipients to keep quiet) but to underscore his sanction to speak for the Father, to forgive, and to rise from the dead. 
  • The speaker removed the phrase "for I am meek and lowly in heart" from Matthew 11:29. The full scripture states, "Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls." Within the full context, the "yoke" is meekness and lowliness, not claiming Jesus as a mascot. 
  • In another passage, the speaker defines the "rock" from the celebrated parable about builders as Jesus Christ. Yet Matthew 7:24 compares building one's house on a rock to "everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice." It is what Jesus does and says that matters, not "owning" Jesus. 
  • The speaker takes John 14:18 out of context. The speaker quotes, "I will not leave you comfortless" as a promise that Jesus will help believers feel better. But the context of the passage is Jesus's promise to send the Spirit to comfort his apostles. He then mentions the Second Coming.
  • The speaker focuses on Jesus's love but fails to focus on Jesus's example. The example of Christ--through his actions and the parables--is to behave with kindness, thoughtfulness, and diligence, not to give over responsibility/make God the fall guy.  

Individually, the above changes might not be serious. Taken together within a single sermon, they are a troubling trend. 

And they portray a modern mindset. Early Christians would have been bemused by the assumptions that underlie the sermon. The Good News in those years meant the opposite of "now, life will be easy/planned out/now, one won't feel so bad." It meant that one might need to choose martyrdom, especially if one wished to emulate Christ in service to the Father. Peace and joy were the peace and joy of personal integrity--more a way of living than an emotional gift certificate. And not to be pursued for themselves.  

I've always (personally) believed that the task of enduring and enjoying life hour by hour and day by day is a much better "sacrifice" than dying. And I do believe that the side-effect of comfort through prayer and worship is possible. 

But a Jesus who is worshiped (rather than the Father) for all the positive feelings he can deliver is not the Jesus of Christianity. That Jesus is VIP who grants insider status: Jesus as life coach. He is not that difficult from a pagan statue that grants prizes or success in games or self-satisfaction to favorites. 

The Jesus of the New Testament is quite different. That Jesus is always pointing beyond himself to what is good, to what he has done, to what he will do, to the Father. 

The quotes below come from the New Testament. They emphasize how both Jesus and letter writers continually point beyond Jesus to what he did, what he advocated, and to the Father. The below list will expand as I add more quotes: 

  • In the same way, let your light shine before others, that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven (Matthew 5:16). 
  •  And I will do whatever you ask in my name, so that the Father may be glorified in the Son (John 14:13).
  • If you loved me, you would be glad that I am going to the Father, for the Father is greater than I (John 14:28) 
  • It is because of him that you are in Christ Jesus, who has become for us wisdom from God (1 Corinthians 30:1).  
  • So whether you eat or drink or whatever you do, do it all for the glory of God (Corinthians 10:31).  
  • Christ loved us and gave himself up for us as a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God (Ephesians 5:2). 
  • Live as children of light (Ephesians 5:8).  
  • Sing and make music from your heart to the Lord, always giving thanks to God the Father for everything, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ (Ephesians 5:19-20).

No comments: